Cake & Cupcake Flavors

  • Wedding Cake ~ Signature light and fluffy vanilla cake. It’s a true white color. Filled with our signature vanilla buttercream icing.
  • Chocolate Fudge ~ A rich dark chocolate and fudge-y cake, perfect for any chocolate fanatic in your life. Filled with our signature and rich chocolate buttercream icing.
  • Strawberry ~ A fruity and extremely popular cake all in the name. Drizzled with our homemade simple syrup and filled with our sweet Strawberry buttercream.
  • Birthday Cake ~ Rainbow sprinkles folded into our light and fluffy white cake, baked to perfection. Filled with our signature vanilla buttercream. A party inside a cake – who wouldn’t want this in their cake?!
  • Snickerdoodle ~ White cake with cinnamon sugar sprinkled and mixed together! It’s LITERALLY a cinnamon roll in cake form. Filled with your choice of cream cheese or vanilla buttercream.
  • Mexican Chocolate ~ Our signature dark chocolate cake with a cinnamon sugar addition mixed together. Filled with our chocolate buttercream, truly an amazing flavor.
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chip ~ Mini chocolate chips folded into our light and fluffy white cake, baked to perfection. Filled with our signature vanilla buttercream. Like a chocolate chip cookie, SO GOOD.
  • Jack Daniel’s® Carrot Cake~ A twist on the classic carrot cake — Add some JD®. The lightest and freshest cake you can eat! If you’re unsure, trust us, it’s been a favorite for over a year! Heck, we even slice it and sell it daily!
  • Cookies N Creme ~ A white cake with Oreo® chunks and crumbs mixed baked for a Oreo® twisted look! Filled with cookies n creme buttercream.
  • Caramel Cake ~ A scrumptious caramel cake with a caramel cream filling. It’s here to stay a while!
  • Pink Champagne ~ Pink Champagne infused into our light and fluffy white cake, baked to perfection. Filled with our signature raspberry buttercream. Whoever loves champagne and pink, this cakes for you!
  • Vanilla Raspberry ~ Our signature white vanilla cake with a combo of raspberry jam + vanilla buttercream. It’s something you will not want to pass up.
  • Red Velvet ~ An American classic of light cocoa combo with unique taste from the buttermilk and vinegar mixture, yes and the red color with the southern mystique. Filled with our signature cream cheese buttercream. An absolute favorite!
  • Mint Chocolate ~ Chocolate mint flavored cake filled with a chocolate or vanilla buttercream icing!
  • Creme Brulee ~ A vanilla style cake filled with our delicious vanilla custard and a vanilla buttercream icing dam. It’s LEGIT SO GOOD.
  • Pina Colada ~ A white pina colada flavored cake, filled with our signature coconut or vanilla buttercream — YOUR CHOICE! Feeling tropical? This one will make you picture everything you’ve been dreamin!
  • Classic Carrot ~ A rich and spice-ful cake with shredded and chopped carrots, without the raisins and tree nuts. Filled with our signature cream cheese buttercream.
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter ~ Our signature dark chocolate fudge cake filled with Peanut Butter (PB) buttercream icing! Reese’s fans where you at?!
  • Lemon Blueberry ~ Lemon citrus and bright cake with a blueberry compote style marbled into the lemon cake! Usually filled with blueberry, lemon, or vanilla buttercream icing!
  • Orange Dream ~ Our orange flavored cake with vanilla buttercream. Identical to an dreamsicle but opposite.
  • Coconut ~ A white coconut cake made with real coconut milk and filled with your choice of vanilla, coconut or cream cheese icing! Something fruity for everyone!
  • Butter ~ A family favorite, rich and buttery yellow cake filled with our signature vanilla or chocolate buttercream. Order this one with all chocolate buttercream everything, like grandma used to make!
  • Almond + Cream Cheese ~ Our super duper moist white almond cake with our sweet and creamy cream cheese buttercream between the layers. *does not contain actual nuts*
  • Chocolate Raspberry ~ Our signature chocolate fudge cake with raspberry infused/mixed together and baked. Filled with raspberry buttercream. Thank us laterrrr
  • Lemon Layer Cake ~ Our world-famous fluffy lemon cake soaked in a tart lemon simple syrup. Filled with lemon buttercream.
  • Italian Creme ~ Classic French vanilla style cake mixed with shredded coconut and finely chopped pecans. Filled with a cream cheese buttercream. *contains actual pecan and coconut*
  • Chocolate Xtreme ~ Like if you believe chocolate wasn’t enough already, this one is beyond something you’d thought of! Our rich dark chocolate cake with chocolate chips baked in, filled with our chocolate fudge buttercream as a dam (around the edge) and THEN filled with dark chocolate ganache. True chocolate geniuses will appreciate!
  • White Chocolate Raspberry ~ Our light and fluffy white cake with melted chocolate baked in with a silky and smooth raspberry buttercream icing layered between.
  • Marble ~ Buttery cake and chocolate fudge marbled together to create a unique design every time! Layered with both vanilla and chocolate buttercream icing.
  • German Chocolate ~ A milk chocolate style cake filled with the classic coconut-pecan custard like filling and a chocolate buttercream dam. A classic in every way possible!
  • Amaretto ~ A family favorite, rich and buttery yellow cake infused with Amaretto liqueur. Order this one with all vanilla buttercream everything. Can’t ever go wrong.
  • Chocolate Kahlua ~ Coffee liqueur flavored dark chocolate fudge cake! Then filled with a chocolate buttercream icing. Coffee & Chocolate together, this simply is almost perfection.

Cakeballs & Cakepops

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Pink Champagne
  • Red Velvet
  • Neopolitan


Cookies

  • Chocolate Chip*
  • Snickerdoodle*
  • Drop Sugar*
  • Decorated Sugar*
  • Oatmeal Raisin
  • Lemon Crinkle
  • White Chocolate Cherry
  • Double Chocolate Chunk
  • Peanut Butter
  • White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
  • Coconut + Pecan
  • denotes available in GF*


Gluten Free Cakes & Cupcakes

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Red Velvet
  • Almond
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Birthday Cake
  • Pink Champagne
  • Chocolate Kahlua


Dairy Free, Vegan, Eggless
Cakes & Cupcakes

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Lemon
  • Red Velvet
  • Almond
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Birthday Cake
  • Pink Champagne
  • Chocolate Kahlua


Cheesecakes

  • New York Style*
  • Strawberry Marble
  • Red Velvet*
  • Chocolate Lovers
  • White Chocolate Strawberry*
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Turtle (contains nuts)
  • Cookies N Creme
  • Irish Creme*
  • denotes available in GF*


Pies

  • Egg Custard*
  • Buttermilk
  • Pecan*
  • Chocolate Pecan*
  • Pumpkin*
  • Sweet Potato*
  • Apple
  • Cherry*
  • Coconut Crème*
  • Lemon Meringue*
  • Banana Cream*
  • denotes available in GF*

Newsletter

We're sharing our insider information with sales, new sweets, and releases! Join our family to get more out of That's The Cake